Skip to main content

Perbandingan INERGEN , NOVEC 1230 dan FM200


Posted February 13, 2018 by Koorsen Fire & Security
When most people think about fire protection in a building, fire sprinkler systemsimmediately come to mind. Sprinkler systems have long been used to protect buildings and the people that use them. However, sprinkler systems are designed to protect the building, not its contents. And, in many settings, they can be a very costly form of fire protection because of the damage that water can do and the clean-up required after they are used. Clean agent fire suppression systems are an ideal supplement to sprinkler systems to protect any type of assets that could be damaged by water.
Clean agent fire suppression systems disperse an inert gas or halocarbon gases to suppress a fire in its incipient stage before reaching the flame/heat stage that would activate the fire sprinkler system. The clean agent systems do not create a health risk for people, they are highly effective, electrically non conducting and leave no residue upon evaporation.
While clean agent systems are rarely required by building or fire codes, businesses and other institutions and organizations are increasingly turning to clean agent fire suppression as a more effective way to protect assets such as:
  • Computer systems including servers, and other electrical components
  • Telecommunications systems
  • Record/file repositories and libraries – anything with paper that must be protected
  • Digital data repositories
  • Cultural assets such as historical buildings, museums, and artwork
  • Flammable liquid storage for which sprinkler systems may not provide proper protection
  • Subfloors with critical building infrastructure that can be damaged with exposure to water
  • Laboratory and medical equipment
The three most common clean agents on the market today are Inert gas (Inergen, Nitrogen, Argonite), Novec 1230, and FM-200, which has been a mainstay of fire suppression systems for more than 20 years. This article provides a comparison of these three popular clean agents to help you decide which might be best for your needs.

How Clean Agents Work

Novec 1230 and FM-200 are clean agent fire suppression compounds made of synthetic chemicals in liquid form and are converted to gas in the discharge process. Both work to extinguish fire and prevent re-ignition by removing the necessary elements of combustion – heat. Unlike Novec 1230 and FM-200, Inert is a gaseous clean agent made up of a mixture of various inert type gases. Inert gas systems work by reducing the oxygen in the space to below that required for combustion.
Clean agents are stored in cylinders and are discharged through a fixed piping system at concentrations calculated based on the area they are intended to protect. All three agents,Inert, Novec 1230, and FM-200 extinguish Class A, B, and C fires, are electrically non-conductive, and will not short-out electronic equipment or thermally shock delicate circuitry. The table below provides some general information for each clean agent.
 Inert GasNovec 1230FM-200
Type of CompoundA mixture of the inert gases: nitrogen, argon, and carbon dioxide (CO2)A fluorinated ketone containing carbon, fluorine, and oxygenA hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) compound containing hydrogen, fluorine, and carbon
Stored as a gasStored as a liquidStored as a liquefied  compressed gas 
Discharge Time60 seconds10 seconds10 seconds
Clean UpNoneNoneNone

Logistical Considerations

When choosing a clean agent fire suppression system, the logistics of the space you are trying to protect is an important consideration. All three of these systems store the clean agent in pressurized cylinders. But, the quantity of suppression agent they can hold depends on the type of agent they use.
Inerts are stored as a gas and discharge as a gas, which requires more agent than halocarbon clean agents, Inert systems will require more cylinders – and more space to store them in – than Novec 1230 and FM-200, which are stored as liquefied compressed gas. Inert gas systems, can be located further away the protected space due to the pressure of each cylinder. Novec 1230 and FM-200 generally must be within or close to the protected space.
In addition to the amount of space required, you also have to consider where that space has to be located relative to the area to be protected space. This is due to how the halocarbon agents converts the liquid into gas as it flows through the system.
With FM-200 and Novec systems, the clean agent is stored as compressed liquid inside the cylinder and is pressurized with dry nitrogen to push the clean agent through the piping system. It is the friction created as the liquid flows under pressure through the discharge piping that turns it into a gas. Compressed liquids don’t flow as well as inert gases, and the pressure at which they flow through the pipe is lower than that of inert gases. As a result, the length of the discharge piping for the FM-200 and Novec systems is more limited than that of the Inert gas systems.
In contrast, the higher pressure in inert gas systems through the discharge piping system and over greater distances. So, while the Inert gas systems requires more cylinders, they can be located further away from the room to be protected. Another advantage of the Inert gas system is that it can be used to protect multiple areas through the use of selector valves, which can also reduce the number of cylinders needed for multiple spaces.
The table below summarizes some of the key differences between these systems that should be considered when choosing a clean agent fire suppression system for your business.
 Inert Gas SystemsNovec 1230 and FM-200 Systems
Proximity of Cylinders to Protected SpaceCan be located further awayMust be located within or very near the space to be protected
Number of Cylinders
Requires more cylinders for the same area protected than Novec 1230 and FM-200 – more storage space but can protect more than one area using selector valvesRequires fewer cylinders for same amount of space to be protected – less storage space than Inert gas systems and also less piping required
Weight of CylindersPressure only, no need to weigh cylinders but pressure must be checked on each cylinder with a calibrated gaugeAgent containers weight and pressure must be checked. Could require removing containers and placing on scale
Ventilation RequirementsRoom pressure venting may be  requiredTypically no special ventilation required

Potential Health Effects of Clean Agents

The “clean” in fire suppression clean agents means that they are safe to use in an occupied area and contain no substances that are toxic to humans.
The likelihood of exposure to the clean agent in the fire suppression system is minimal if the proper warning and alarm systems are in place to give occupants sufficient time to evacuate. With ample training for personnel and understanding of how the clean agent systems operates, the risks are minimal.
But, even with clean agents, too much of a good thing can be dangerous. Novec 1230, FM-200 and Inert gas systems all have concentration limitations. Proper design flow calculations are necessary to ensure the amount of agent is discharged for the cubic volume will result in a safe concentration for whatever agent you’re using.
Testing and certification laboratories assign different types of values to indicate the relative safety of clean agents and to guide proper engineering of the systems that use them. The table below compares Inerts, FM-200, and Novec 1230 in the following terms:
  • Design Concentration – Concentration of agent in the protected space that are safe for occupied spaces to extinguish Class A, B or C type fires.
  • The No Observable Adverse Effects Level (NOAEL) – The highest concentration at which adverse toxilogical or psychological effect has been observed.
  • Safety Margin – The margin of safety for a clean agent is calculated based on the NOAEL and the use concentration. The less agent you have to use (design concentration) relative to the concentration at which adverse effects are observed
  • Lowest Observable Adverse Effect Level (LOEAL), The lowest concentration at which an adverse psychological or toxicological effects have been observed.
 Inert GasNovec 1230FM-200
Use Concentration34.2-42%4.0-6.0%6.7-8.7%
No Observable Adverse Effects Level (NOAEL)

Environmental Considerations

Historically, the main environmental concern with clean agent fire suppression systems has been their effect on the Earth’s ozone layer. When the problem of ozone depletion was discovered in 1985, the fire safety industry began looking for alternatives to the Halon-based compounds used in clean agent fire suppression systems at the time.
Halon is a Monobrotrifluoromethane with very high ozone depletion properties. Its production was banned in 1994 under the Clean Air Act. While it is still legal to purchase and use recycled Halon, eventually, the diminishing supply will require businesses with halon-based fire suppression systems to replace their Halon systems with systems that use readily available alternatives such as Inert gas, Novec 1230 and FM-200.
FM-200 – a hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) – was the first replacement for Halon that promised no impacts to the ozone layer. It is important to note that there are no regulations against using FM-200. It is still manufactured and widely used in clean agent fire suppression systems. However, the increasing concern over global warming has given rise to newer alternatives such as Novec 1230 – the first clean agent on the market to boast no impact to the ozone layer or global warming – and Inerts.
 Inert GasNovec 1230FM-200
Ozone Depletion Potential (ODP)NoneNoneNone
Global Warming Potential (GWP)
None1 (equivalent to that of carbon dioxide)3500 
Atmospheric Lifetime (years)

Clean Agent Fire Suppression Systems Maintenance

The NFPA 2001 Standard on Clean Agent Fire Extinguishing Systems requires that your system as a whole must be inspected annually. The cylinders must be checked for weight and/or pressure every six months to ensure they have the required quantity of clean agent and that they are properly pressurized.


  1. When you are alone, you can not exactly ask anyone to get your medication for you, so if you collapse due to a issue that one of your medications can fix, the pill case in your pocket will be your best friend. medic alert

  2. Thank you so much for such an informative piece of information :)
    If anyone interested similar one's have a look here


  3. Great Post, This is giving more valuable information and contains a lot of information. This post is very useful for me as well as for others so please share more posts like this. Thanks for sharing. Sprinkler companies Maumee

  4. Hi to every single one, it’s truly a good for me to visit this web page, I love your content, they are very nice and it includes helpful Information. Check out our website Fire Door Survey for more Noor Construction Consultants Ltd related info! I am truly pleased to read this website posts which carries lots of helpful data, thanks for providing these kinds of statistics.

  5. The article you have shared here about this topic is really significant for us. I'm happy that you have shared this great info with us. Keep posting, Thank you. Fire Protection

  6. Extremely useful information which you have shared here about paramount wastewater solutions for us .This is a great way to enhance knowledge for us, and also beneficial for us. Thank you for sharing an article like this.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cara Menghitung Ampere Motor 3 dan 1 Phase dengan Rumus Daya

Sering kali, anda menjumpai motor listrik untuk menggerakan mesin pada pabrik - pabrik sekarang dan kebanyakan 85% didalam pabrik menggunakan motor listrik untuk menggerakan mesinnya. motor listrik ada 2 jenis Phase yang pertama adalah 3 phase yang di mana ada tegangan R S T sedangkan yang ke dua adalah 1 Phase dimana motor listrik hanya diberi tegangan phase dan Netral aja, contohnya seperti pumpa air dirumah.     Dari motor - motor tersebut maka anda sangat perlu untuk menghitung amperenya dimana anda membeli motor 1 phase tapi kapasitas rumah anda hanya 450 Watt saja maka anda harus menghitung motor airnya harus di bawah dari 450 Watt. Plate Motor 1 Phase  Diatas adalah name plate motor 1 phase dimana   sudah di ketahui KW dan Amperenya jika hanya di   ketahui KWnya saja bagaimana seperti berikut   menghitungya:  Diket : P : 8 KW = 8 x 1000 = 8000 Watt V : 220V Ditanya : Berapa Nilai Amperenya? Rumus daya  Motor 1 Phase: P = V x I I  = P/V Keterangan : P  : Daya ( Watt ) I   : Arus

Cara Menghitung Satuan Volt, Ampere, dan Watt

Sangat penting untuk mengetahui satuan dalam bidang yang ingin anda pahami, dalam bidang listrik untuk mengetahui satuan seperti volt, ampere, dan watt. Ketika anda tidak mengetahui satuan dari bidang listrik ini sama saja dengan tidak tahu dalam teori dasar dan anda sekarang bisa memperlajari dengan jelas dalam artikel saya berikan ini. Saya akan memberikan langkah demi langkah agar mudah untuk dipahami. Pengertian Volt (Voltage) Volt (Voltage) adalah standart satuan listrik yang menunjukan atau menerangkan sebuah nilai tegangan dalam listrik. Volt atau bisa disebut tegangan hanya bisa diukur dengan alat yang bernama voltmeter atau multitester, volt mempunyai bermacam-macam nilai tegangan dan juga tipe atau karekter yang berbeda. Volt Mempunyai 2 tipe atau karakter Volt atau tegangan listrik ini mempunyai jenis 2 tipe yaitu tegangan AC atau bisa disebut tegangan bolak-balik. kemudian tegangan DC (Direct Current) atau bisa disebut dengan tegangan searah. Untuk mengatahui apa itu tegan

Alat - Alat Fiber Optic dan Fungsinya

1. Fusion Splicer Fusion splicer atau sering dikenal sebagai alat untuk menyambungkan serat optik ini merupakan salah satu alat yang digunakan untuk menyambungkan sebuah core serat optik, dimana serat tersebut terbuat / berbasis kaca, dan mengimplementasikan suatu daya listrik yang telah dirubah menjadi sebuah media sinar berbentuk laser. Sinar laser tersebut berfungsi untuk memanasi kaca yang terputus pada core sehingga bisa tersambung kembali dengan baik. Perlu kalian ketahui, bahwa fusion splicer ini haruslah memiliki tingkat keakuratan yang cukup tinggi, hal ini ditujukan untuk menghasilkan hasil penyambungan yang sempurna, karena pada saat penyambungan tersebut akan terjadi proses pengelasan media kaca serta peleburan kaca yang akan menghasilkan suatu media, dimana media tersebut akan tersambung dengan utuh tanpa adanya celah-celah, hal ini dikarenakan media tersebut memiliki senyawa yang sama. 2. Stripper Atau Miller Sama seperti kabel - kabel yang lain, salah satunya seperti kab

Cara Menentukan Ukuran Kabel Instalasi Listrik

Dalam sebuah instalasi listrik di sebuah rumah atau bangunan, penggunaan kabel listrik haruslah diperhatikan betul. Mengingat kesalahan penggunaan dan pemasangan kabel dapat membahayakan manusia atau penghuni rumah. Dalam menggunakan sebuah kabel ini dari anda harus tahu jenis kabel yang akan di pasang, berapa ukuran kabel listrik, luas penampang maupun panjang kabel listrik. Ukuran Kabel Listrik Seperti yang kita ketahui bersama bahwa fungsi sebuah kabel listrik adalah untuk menghantarkan arus listrik dari sumber listrik menuju beban daya suatu alat listrik. Yang dimaksud dengan ukuran kabel lisrik adalah luas penampang kabel . Sehingga setiap ukuran kabel listrik akan menggunakan satuan mm2 . Mengapa menggunakan ukuran kabel yang tepat sangat penting ? karena kesalahan dalam penentuan ukuran kabel dapat menyebabkan resiko yang fatal. Beberapa kode yang sering ditemukan pada sebuah kabel listrik yaitu : 1 X   1,5 mm 1 X   2,5 mm 2 X   1,5 mm 2 X   2,5 mm Keterangan : Angka sebelum kal

Fungsi dan Cara Setting MCCB ( Moulded Case Circuit Breaker )

Mengulas lebih dalam tentang MCCB - dunia listrik sangat banyak sekali peralatan listrik sebagai pengaman untuk keselamatan dari bahaya listrik maupun untuk mengamankan sebuah motor dan peralatan listrik lainya dari bahaya short circuit. Apa itu MCCB ? MCCB adalah singkatan dari Moulded Case Circuit Breaker, sebagai pengaman terjadinya hubung singkat short circuit dan beban lebih overload agar tidak terjadinya kerusakan pada motor listrik maupun kebakaran yang disebabkan oleh short circuit yang selalu menimbulkan bunga api. MCCB biasanya digunakan oleh industri karena MCCB hanya untuk pengaman listrik 3 phase, dan motor listrik industri juga menggunakan listrik 3 phase, jadi jika anda ingin bertemu apa itu namanya mccb dan dan digunakan untuk apa mampir deh pabrik terdekat dan minta tolong untuk dilihatkan apa itu mccb. Pole MCCB Mccb memiliki macam – macam pole: 1 Pole, 2 Pole, 3 Pole, 4 Pole Mccb memiliki macam – macam kA: 36kA, 50kA, 85kA, 100kA Karakter MCCB - Hanya menggunakan 3 p

Perbedaan Antara KW, KVA, KWH, KVAr

Apa definisi KVA, KW, Watt, KWH, KVar, dan apa perbedaannya? Mungkin kita pernah menjumpai satuan listrik yang terkadang ditulis dengan menggunakan Watt, KW, atau KVA, Dan ini sering menjadi pertanyaan bagi kita, apa sebenarnya perbedaan satuan KW dan KVA, dan berapa 1 kVA, atau mungkin berapa itu 1 KVA KW? Selain itu kita juga sering mendengar istilah KWH, maka pertanyaannya, 1 KWH berapa Watt, atau 1 Kw berapa KWH? Untuk menjawab pertanyaan tersebut, berikut penjelasan mengenai apa yang dimaksud dengan KVA, KW, Watt, KWH, Kvar, dan apa perbedaannya. Apa yang dimaksud dengan KVA, KW, KVAr, dan KWH? Dalam listrik tiga fasa, terdapat 3 jenis daya listrik yang disebut juga dengan segitiga daya, yaitu: Daya Semu (KVA) Daya Aktif (KW) Daya Reaktif (KVAr) KVA KVA (Kilo Volt Ampere) untuk daya listrik yang tidak terlalu besar biasanya cukup menggunakan satuan daya VA (Volt Ampere). 1 KVA = 1000VA KVA adalah satuan daya listrik yang diperoleh dari perhitungan rumus daya, atau biasa disebut de

10 Virtual appliances yang memudahkan pekerjaan Anda.

10 virtual appliances that can simplify your job By  Jack Wallen September 27, 2012, 10:43 AM PDT Takeaway:  If you’ve never worked with virtual appliances, you owe it to yourself to check them out. Here are 10 good ones that will give you an idea of what they can do for you. When you need to quickly deploy a server or test a server-based application, one of the best means of doing so is by using a virtual appliance. A virtual appliance is essentially a prebuilt virtual machine of a configured server that offers any number of features or services. There are virtual appliances for ERP, CRM, file serving, groupware, and just about every type of server you can think of. You can download complete operating systems or powerful services built on top of full-blown server OSes. I have rounded up 10 of my favorite turnkey solutions, which you can download and load up into your favorite virtual machine host to deploy or test. Since there are hundreds upon hundreds of these types o


Pengertian Panel Listrik Panel listrik adalah suatu benda berbentuk kubus dengan berbagai ukuran ataupun bervariasi dengan sebelah sisi dibuat lubang selebar hampir sama dengan belakangnya, dan nantinya di baut penutup seperti daun pintu agar bisa dibuka dan ditutup, dan didalam panel tersebut terdapat papan yang dikaitkan dengan sisi belakang pintu di pakai baut yang nantinya papan tersebut dapat dilepas dan dipasang kembali. Pada umumnya panel listrik adalah terbuat dari plat besi dengan ketebalan 0,5 – 1 mm. Biasanya disesuaikan dengan ukuran atau besarnya panel, dan nantinya papan tersebut yang akan digunakan tempat pemasangan komponen-komponen listrik. Fungsi Panel Listrik Fungsi dari panel listrik adalah untuk menempatkan komponen listrik sebagai pendukung dari mesin-mesin listrik agar bisa beroperasi  sesuai dengan prinsip kerja dari mesin listrik itu sendiri. Untuk mengamankan komponen listrik supaya terlindungi dari pengaruh di sekelilingnya. Untuk menata komponen atau rangkai

Semakin banyak SME yang menggunakan PRTG

Enterprise Management Associates (EMA) is an analyst firm with a strong focus on IT and data management. In his new report "Network Management Megatrends 2016" EMA's infrastructure management specialist Shamus McGillicuddy analyzes the influence of current technologies such as Internet of Things or Hybrid Cloud on today's network management, based on a survey with IT professionals from 150 enterprises. Since most of our customers are SME we asked McGillicuddy to create a white paper based on his report, with a special focus on the special requirements of small and midsize enterprises. Executive Summary Network managers at small and medium enterprises face many of the same challenges that their counterparts at large enterprises face, plus a few of their own. For instance, networking professionals at smaller companies often operate enterprise-grade technologies with fewer resources and smaller budgets. Therefore, these individuals need network

Jenis Kabel Listrik beserta Fungsi dan Gambarnya

Berbicara mengenai kabel listrik tentu sangat luas sekali. Kabel listrik sendiri merupakan komponen yang memiliki peran vital dalam berbagai peralatan elektronik yang kita gunakan sehari-hari. Dari kegunaannya, jenis-jenis kabel listrik ini sangat banyak dan beragam. Pemakaian jenis kabel pun harus tepat agar tidak menyebabkan konsleting listrik. Untuk itu penting sekali mengetahui jenis jenis kabel listrik berikut ini. Kabel listrik Kabel listrik merupakan sebuah komponen konduktor yang berfungsi untuk menghantarkan arus listrik ke benda-benda atau peralatan yang membutuhkan energi listrik agar dapat bekerja. Meskipun jenis-jenis kabel listrik sangat banyak, tetapi pada umumnya setiap kabel listrik terdiri dari dua bagian utama, yakni bagian isolator dan bagian konduktor. Bagian-bagian Kabel Listrik Pada kabel listrik, bahan isolator merupakan bahan yang tidak dapat menghantarkan arus listrik. Pada isolator terdiri dari pembungkus kabel yang memiliki fungsi sebagai pelindung (agar tid