Skip to main content


Fixing Indonesian Education's Poor Scores

Bruce Gale - Straits Times Indonesia | October 07, 2011

Indonesia ranks 61st out of 65 countries when it comes to 15-year-olds' proficiency in mathematics. Their reading skills are a little better, with teenagers in only seven countries performing worse. (JG Photo/ Yudhi Sukma Wijaya)

Indonesia ranks 61st out of 65 countries when it comes to 15-year-olds' proficiency in mathematics. Their reading skills are a little better, with teenagers in only seven countries performing worse. This is the conclusion of a study carried out in 2009 by the Program for International Student Assessment (Pisa) and coordinated by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

Why are Indonesian youngsters so far behind? Some observers believe the problem arises from a lack of sufficient funding for education. Others blame it on a corrupt and poorly designed national examination system.

These are certainly contributing factors.

An equally serious problem may be the education system's continued emphasis on rote learning and the failure of the nation's bureaucrats to use available funds wisely.

One of the great achievements of the Suharto era was the establishment of universal education and the subsequent spread of literacy. But the system has since fallen into disrepute.

Educationalists also point to a greater divergence in the quality of education available as the children of middle- and upper-class citizens gravitate to better-funded private schools and religious organizations struggle to provide a good education to the less privileged.

After decades of neglect, however, education spending has increased enormously in recent years and is now equivalent to about 3.4 per cent of gross domestic product, around the same level as Singapore's. Even so, much remains to be done. In July, Anwar Alsaid, head of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization's education unit in Jakarta, urged Indonesia to continue to focus on the sector.

The government seems to be taking notice. Later the same month, the local press reported that the National Education Ministry had allocated 762.2 billion rupiah (S$111 million) to fund scholarships for more than two million students from low-income families. The scholarships are to go to elementary school pupils in the first to fifth grades.

Since 2006, the government has also been working to address concerns about the need for quality education. So-called "international-standard schools" or RSBIs with more diverse curriculums and fewer students in each class have been created. These schools, of which there are currently about 1,300 across the country, are allowed to impose fees - a point which has prompted critics to complain that students from low-income families have been effectively excluded.

But the more fundamental complaint against RSBIs is that they have so far failed to deliver on their promise of academic excellence. And scholarships serve little purpose if the quality of education remains poor. Earlier this year, the Education Ministry stopped issuing additional RSBI permits pending an evaluation.

Educationalist Toenggoel Siagian sees a fundamental problem with the way Indonesian students in government schools are taught. "They don't teach students English. Rather, they teach them about English," he told me when I met him recently in Jakarta. Siagian's lament concerned the emphasis on English grammar at the expense of practical skills such as the ability to carry on simple conversations.

He has a point. Despite the fact that English is a compulsory subject at the senior high school level, few graduates of government schools can hold a simple conversation in the language. Mathematics, says Siagian, is generally taught better. But even here there is little attempt in schools to link the subject to the real world in a way that would help students solve practical problems.

Siagian heads the Jakarta Christian School Association (PSKD), which runs 22 primary, junior high and senior high schools in the Jakarta area. Many PSKD schools are well regarded for the quality of the education they provide despite the relatively modest fees charged.

Speaking to me in his office in Jakarta's Kwini district, Siagian also placed emphasis on the need to give students something to be proud of. As an example, he pointed to the girls' basketball team at PSKD's senior high school in Kwini. Membership of the team, which regularly wins national championships, is highly prized by the students. But no student can be admitted into the team with a high grade point average.

A committed staff also helps. PSKD's head of academic affairs holds a PhD from Cornell University in the United States. Yet she earns just 3.5 million rupiah a month and is not entitled to any additional allowances. Similarly committed educationalists can be found in some of the better Muslim schools run by organizations such as the Nahdlatul Ulama.

Such individuals, however, will probably always be in the minority. More realistically, Siagian speaks about the need to improve teacher training and raise salaries so that more of the country's better university graduates will consider teaching as a career.

Money is important. But it needs to be spent in the right places. There also needs to be a fundamental rethink about educational methods and goals if Indonesia's teenagers are to perform better in future Pisa assessments.

Reprinted courtesy of Straits Times Indonesia. To subscribe to Straits Times Indonesia and/or the Jakarta Globe call 021 2553 5055.
build-access-manage on


Popular posts from this blog

Timer AC bergantian

Bagaimana sich prinsip kerja AC yang bergantian? Seperti yang terangkai pada ACPDB, yang kita butuhkan adalah 1 buah timer dan 2 buah kontaktor. Pada dasarnya rangkaiannya adalah seperti gambar diatas. Seperti kita ketahui, timer dan kontaktor akan bekerja apabila mendapatkan catuan 220 V. Pada timer catuan bisa dikoneksikan di lubang “L” dan “N”, sedang pada kontaktor dilubang “A1” dan “A2”. Itulah kenapa pada saat mati listrik komponen2 tersebut tidak bekerja. Timer berfungsi sebagai switch dari 2-1 atau 2-3 dan lubang “2” sebagai sumber yang dialiri arus listrik. Sesuai namanya alat ini akan bergantian dari 2-1 atau 2-3 berdasarkan waktu yang sudah kita atur pada sirip biru. Satu sirip merepresentasikan 30 menit. Sedang pada kontaktor untuk tipe Telemecanique, sumbu-sumbu saklarnya adalah 1-2, 3-4, 5-6, NO-NO, NC-NC.  Jika “A1” dan “A2” tidak dicatu maka 1-2 (open), 3-4 (open), 5-6 (open), NO-NO (open), NC-NC (close/terhubung). Dan bila “A1” dan “A2” dicatu  maka 1-2 (close), 3-4 (clo…

Pemilihan jenis modul AMF (Automatic Main Failure)

Pemilihan jenis modul AMF (Automatic Main Failure)

Dari sekian banyak jenis modul yang ada dipasaran, kami menawarkan beberapa alternatif untuk jenis modul AMF yang dapat kami sediakan. antara lain menggunakan modul dari DEEPSEA, smart relay atau timer. tentunya dengan beragam pilihan tersebut ada beberapa keuntungan atau kelebihan dari masing masing modul tersebut. sebagai misal menggunakan modul AMF dari DEEPSEA akan sangat cocok jika modul ini dapat berinterakasi langsung dengan genset. terutama jika mesin genset belum dilengkapi genset controller dan masih mengandalkan panel genset manual. untuk pabrikan genset sekarang ini pada panel genset sudah dilengkapi dengan AMF, sehingga tidak perlu panel AMF - ATS dengan menggunakan modul DEEPSEA atau sejenisnya. sehingga dalam pemilihanya dapat menggunakan timer, smart relay atau produk lain seperti ATS controller C20 dari socomec.

Modul DEEPSEA 4420

AMF Module DSE 4420 Modul ini memiliki banyak fitur antara lain ; Start / stop gensetDigital …

Mendesigns dan Menghitung UPS untuk Data Center

Mendesigns dan Menghitung UPS untuk Data Center UPS dan data center mungkin bisa di sebut sayur tanpa garam, hambar jika tidak saling melengkapi. 
Tapi untuk menentukan kebutuhan akan UPS data centerperlu perhitungan yang matang agar UPS dan server tetap awet dan selalu ON 24 jam. banyak sekali jenis UPS dan daya yang di tawarkan. Kita harus menghitung kebutuhan beban keseluruhan server agar ketika listrik down UPS dapat menghandle beberapa detik untuk listrik pindah ke genset begitu pula sebaliknya, Oke untuk menentukan itu semua tentukan dulu jenis UPS yang akan anda gunakan.
Oke kita sedikit belajar dulu tentang UPS :)
PRINSIP KERJA UPS Setiap PC membutuhkan daya listrik. Apabila aliran listrik (main power) terputus, PC akan mati (tidak berfungsi). Fungsi dasar UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply) adalah menyediakan suplai listrik SEMENTARA ke beban (PC) tanpa terputus pada saat main power tidak bekerja agar seluruh proses dapat dihentikan dengan benar, seluruh data dapat disimpan den…